- Light
- Forschung
Published: | By: Gender in Focus
Artificial neural networks play a crucial role in the utilisation and analysis of large amounts of data. One particular field of application for Psychology and Medicine research is the recognition and classification of human facial expressions. The systems used for this are very powerful and are developed as automated processes (end-to-end) for processing large data sets and trained accordingly. However, these black box models often exhibit irregular behaviour when used, especially in the case of subpopulation shifts (mixture shock), which impairs the performance and validity of the predictions.
ComputerExternal link scientists from the Computer Vision Group JenaExternal link, led by Professor Joachim Denzler, have taken up this problem and analysed in a recent study which factors could have an influence on the irregular behaviour of AI models for the recognition of facial expressions. Two common applications (HSEmotion-7 and ResidualMaskNet), which are able to recognise a total of six basic emotions as well as a neutral expression, were selected for this purpose. Together with the Otorhinolaryngology Department under the direction of Professor Orlando Guntinas-Lichius at Jena University Hospital (JUH), 36 healthy volunteers were initially asked to express the various emotions in a random order in front of a camera in a standardised procedure. In order to avoid distortions caused by human attributions, the focus was exclusively on the participants' ability to express facial expressions, which was recorded using frontal shots. In order to take into account the application context in neurological diagnostics, the recordings were made four times with and twice without the applied electrodes of the high-resolution surface electromyography. A second group of subjects consisted of 36 patients with unilateral facial paralysis, the appearance of which can be accepted as having a demonstrable influence on the quality of AI model predictions. These images with the different facial expressions were taken using 3D scans.
Do AI models perceive emotions differently in men and women? This diagram illustrates how two AI models exhibit gender bias when recognising facial expressions. The data on the left shows that the first AI model often has difficulty recognising the facial expression ‘disgust’ in men compared to women. On the right-hand side, it can be seen that a second model attributes the facial expression ‘happy’ (joy) to women more often and with greater certainty. These findings help researchers uncover hidden biases in modern medical and psychological AI tools.
Graphic: Computer Vision Group JenaFor further analysis, the researchers selected several relevant characteristics of facial features that could influence models for facial recognition. In addition to the (non-)application of electrodes and diseases such as facial nerve palsy, these include factors such as age, weight and gender as well as the symmetry of facial proportions. The black box models were then 'put to the test' and the researchers were able to show that some of these characteristics are significantly included in the decision-making process of AI models and therefore influence the probability of accurate predictions. In relation to gender, for example, it was proven and confirmed that the activation for the prediction "happy" is on average more pronounced in women. Furthermore, the term "disgusted" was weighted lower for men than for women.
With this insight into the black box of data processing, Tim Büchner, Niklas Penzel and Joachim Denzler from the Computer Vision Group Jena and Orlando Guntinas-Lichius from the ENT Clinic have provided an important impetus to continue critically evaluating the functioning of AI models and highlighting possible sources of error in order to make the models even better and more powerful in the future, especially for Medicine and psychological applications.
The research was funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG) within the project 427899908 BRIDGING THE GAP: MIMICS AND MUSCLES (DE 735/15-1 and GU 463/12-1).
Tim Büchner, Niklas Penzel, Orlando Guntinas-Lichius, and Joachim Denzler: The Power of Properties: Uncovering the Influential Factors in Emotion Classification. In: Christian Wallraven, Cheng-Lin Liu, Arun Ross (Eds.): Pattern Recognition and Artificial Intelligence. 4th 欧洲杯投注地址_明升体育-竞彩足球比分推荐 Conference, ICPRAI 2024. p. 440-448, 2025.
Joachim Denzler, Univ.-Prof. Dr
Orlando Guntinas-Lichius, Univ.-Prof. Dr
07747 Jena Google Maps site planExternal link